Chinese Whisperings: The Red Book is a collection of ten interwoven short stories by emerging writers from across the English-speaking world, a conceptual anthology created by Australian writer Jodi Cleghorn and Scottish writer Paul Anderson. This collection, the first in a series of anthologies to be published under the Chinese Whisperings imprint, sees each successive writer taking a minor character from the preceding story and telling their story as the major character in the next. Unlike other anthologies, which might be unified by theme or year of writing, Chinese Whisperings: The Red Book has been created in a sequential fashion, the stories taking place in the same American University town, each writer often referencing events from the preceding stories to tie the ten stories together.
The setting does not limit the subject matter or theme of each piece and all the stories are individual enough to be read in isolation; yet together they become more than a sum of the parts. Often while working through the collection I found myself sucked into a particular story to then discover just how it how it links in to the larger framework. Rather than kicking you out of the present story, the effect is one of cohesion, as the connections are revealed in an organic and natural way that is increasingly satisfying the further you wade into The Red Book’s narratives. All this drives the reader forward through the collection.
Characters and storylines are surprisingly varied considering the structural and character constraints the editors and writers set themselves, moving from the perspective of an aid worker to that of a homeless man via a sleep deprived librarian and a violent street thug. The ten characters’ stories move between the internalised, such as Miranda’s, where she considers how she has come to be trapped in the clutches of a mysterious illness or Simon’s, who in the midst of sleep deprivation begins to hallucinate, and more externalised plots concerning private detectives, violent criminals and corrupt organisations.
While none of the stories feel out of place within the collection, the most successful tales, for this reader at least, are those that are the most intimate. ‘Mercurial’ is an intense, claustrophobic piece that sees Miranda trapped as much by her actions as by the sickness that assails her. ‘Not Myself’ has an hallucinatory quality that captures the wanderings of a sleep deprived mind while showing the causes can often be both more mundane and more exciting than one might think. ‘Heartache’ is a moving tale of loss, with the main character seeking reasons for actions he cannot explain.
When the stories delve into the realm of genre fiction, they still retain some of that intimacy, which helps create the strong unity of the collection. The final tale, ‘One in the Chamber,’ provides a complimentary bookend to opener ‘Mercurial,’ its use of noirish detective fiction creating a contrasting sense of claustrophobia to that of the opening tale. ‘Not My Name’ and ‘Discovery’ expand the narrative beyond the American university town setting into other continents while bonds both thematic and character driven pull the stories back into the fictional gravity well of the setting and the collection as a whole. It is this breadth of genre and style within the collection that ensures there is something for everyone within its (currently virtual) covers.
What is perhaps most striking about The Red Book is the fact that, on finishing the final tale, it leaves the reader with a desire to return to the beginning and experience the various threads of plot and character again, certain that a second read will unlock deeper complexities of connection. In fact, this is encouraged by the editors with the creation of The Red Book Reversed. Whichever direction you end up tackling these stories, the Red Book comes highly recommended as an interesting concept that manages to live up to its promise.
The Red Book is available here as an eBook via Paypal buttons in a whole host of currencies, so wherever you are in the world it’s easy to snag a copy. A paperback edition will be available March 2010. It’s also worth following CW on twitter @ChineseWhisAnth to get all the latest news and be in with a chance of winning one of the limited edition Red Book Reversed ebooks. In this digital only edition the stories are presented in reverse order, with each main character slinking into the background of subsequent stories creating all sorts of interesting new continuities.
In the interests of full disclosure, I will be writing for Chinese Whisperings – The Jade Book, due later this year. This review was note drafted before I was invited to join the CW crew. The enjoyment I got from reading this first collection (in two sittings, driven on by desire to see just how the next tale fits into the overall continuity) was a major factor in my jumping at the chance to take part in the next.
11 Responses to Chinese Whisperings: The Red Book – review.
I will be joining you in writing for the Jade Book. I’m very excited about the project!
Thank you so much Dan for this amazing review.
I feel like a job well done after reading this – and love your feedback on the individual stories and the anthology as a whole.
I never considered ‘One in the Chamber’ to have a claustrophobic feel about it, but now that you’ve mentioned it – it certainly does. I can remember editing it with Paul and can sense that it wasn’t only the darkness I could feel, but a sense of uncomfortable containment.
When you tell people to write ‘mainstream’ fiction they all bring their own slants to it, and I’m grateful for all the slants and different dimensions the authors bought to their individual narratives and the anthology narrative as a whole.
And again, as with Jen’s review, jumping for joy to see you were compelled to keep reading, which was why in the intial conceptual stages I chose to create the anthology this way (and then see it to Paul as an idea which would work, then to eight other writers) I have only ever read two anthologies back to back. I always get distracted from story to story – thus I wanted the reader here, to keep on moving from story to story. And to see it has been achieved brings to fruition the promse from Paul earlier last year … that when we were finished the view from the top was going to be awesome. And it is.
Thank you so much for taking the time to review The Red Book and we’re very pleased and excited to have you onboard for the next anthology. Are we for you Laura as well!
Wow, thanks for such an amazing review! (I wrote ‘Heartache’ by the way) It has been a thrilling project, and seeing it being well received is so exciting.
As one of the writers, it’s also very interesting to hear feedback about the holistic experience of the book, as I only read the story before mine, and then wrote heartache, so during the creation phase, it was impossible to know it as a whole. What you say about the benefits of the interwoven stories demonstrates just how much work and careful thought Jodi and Paul put in to weave them all together.
I will be writing for the next one too, hooray! Looking forward to getting to know you more through that 🙂
thanks for the great review Dan. We were all a bit nervous and ready to bite back the pain of total rejection … but it never happened……phew! Thank you for your honesty and indepth study of the collection.
Cheers
Annie
Thanks for stopping by, everyone. The Red Book really is a great read. I keep having the urge to dive back in. Something I should have mentioned in the review was the consistent quality in the collection to. There really wasn’t a story I didn’t enjoy.
Hats off to the authors and Jodi and Paul for pulling it all together.
Really excited to be part of the next collection.
Did you get a copy of The Red Book Reversed. There’s a perfect excuse to dive back and read again 🙂
We wored hard and pushed all the writers to ensure there was a consistency of quality the whole way through. I’m certain at times I wasn’t the writers favourite person, as I pushed hard, asked for another rewrite, twiddled, played and re-arranged things… but all the authors are still talking to me… so I couldn’t have been that horrible to work with. And glad it has paid dividends.
Got my copy of the Red Book Reversed, thanks, and it’s all cued up in my Sony reader ready for when I get a few hours to blast through a chunk of stories. Having read once I know how much I’ll want to keep reading so a decent chunk of time is a must. 🙂
I have on my to-do list – to convert the book to ePub format – compliments of Jen B who did it and said the quality of conversion was excellent – in terms of layout.
Neither Paul nor I have eReaders so it was a bit hit and miss creating the eBook.
I’m so chuffed to hear you have to put away a chunk of time even with the second read. Really inspires me to go hard this year.
I’d bite your hand off or give my right one for epub versions of the book as when I increase the PDF files text size the formatting goes a little bonkers. 🙂
What Dan said. I LOVE my Kindle.
[…] Book and The Yin & Yang Book are almost upon us. Those of you with long memories will remember I reviewed the digital release of The Red Book and before going on to become one of twenty emerging authors, ten male and ten female, selected to […]
Comments are closed.